California Tenant Law

Understanding Landlords

If you've come to this page, it's probably because you're a reasonable, intelligent person, who lives by the Golden Rule and treats other people the way you want to be treated. And you're having trouble with a landlord who is decidedly not any of those things.

How can they act this way?

You're not crazy. You're just in the Tenant Zone. Here's a guide.

Reptilian Thinking

Some people operate at a primitive, reptilian level. It's predator-prey thinking. Their brains are hard-wired to see others as either predators (to be feared and avoided) or prey (to be exploited). When they see a tenant being reasonable and accommodating, they see prey. The more reasonable you are, the more they take advantage.

The solution: you need to bare your teeth and claws. When a reptilian thinker sees that you can bite back, they suddenly become very reasonable. It's not about being aggressive — it's about showing that you're not prey. A strongly worded letter from a lawyer, a well-researched citation of the law, or even just the confidence that comes from knowing your rights can completely change the dynamic.

Arrogance

Many landlords carry a feudal attitude — they own the land, and the tenants are the serfs. This attitude has deep historical roots, and it manifests as pure arrogance. They believe they can do whatever they want because it's "their property."

The truth is, arrogance is usually a mask for weakness. Arrogant people are often deeply insecure and compensate by pushing others around. The key is to not engage with the arrogance but to speak to them as a parent would to a misbehaving child — firmly, clearly, and without emotion. State the law, state your rights, and state the consequences of their continued behavior.

Little People with Power

Resident managers and property management staff are often the worst offenders. These are people who may have very little power or status in their own lives, and suddenly they're given authority over dozens of tenants. The power goes straight to their heads.

They make up rules, they play favorites, they retaliate against anyone who complains. The key to dealing with them is to go over their heads. Document everything, and communicate directly with the property owner or management company in writing. The little tyrant usually backs down quickly when their boss gets involved.

In My Country...

Some landlords come from countries where tenants have virtually no rights, and landlords are part of the aristocratic class. They bring those attitudes to California, not realizing (or not caring) that the law here is very different.

The approach: get the government involved early. A code enforcement inspection, a letter from a lawyer citing California law, or a complaint to the local housing authority sends a clear message: "This isn't your country. There are rules here."

My Temple

Some landlords inherited their rental property or lived in it before renting it out. To them, it's not a business — it's their home, their temple, their sacred space that you're merely allowed to occupy. They have unrealistic expectations about how you should treat "their" home, and they take every scuff mark as a personal insult.

These landlords need firm boundaries. Remind them (in writing) that once they rented the property, it became your home under the law. You have the right to live in it normally. Normal wear and tear is not damage. And their emotional attachment to the property does not give them the right to violate your privacy or your lease.

Kenneth H. Carlson

California Tenant Law

Request a consultation

Ready to Talk to an Attorney?

Request an initial consultation with an experienced tenant rights attorney. We've been helping California tenants since 1980.

Request Initial Consultation
Request Consultation